Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Susan Cortilet Jones (link ⬇️)'s avatar

Persistence...overcomes resistance...that is how I see you Dr. Lee. I’m heartbroken that you and your sister’s lives have been dedicated to uncovering such evil. I’m sorry that your niece and nephew have had to endure such pain.

Expand full comment
James R. Carey's avatar

Q: What do the data from the field of psychology’s most important and most misunderstood experiment teach us about cruelty?

A: The oscilloscope readout from Benjamin Libet’s famous experiment shows a cognitive process between a stimulus and a voluntary behavioral response. The process lasts roughly 500 ms (one half second) and is comprised of two phases. Unconscious intent is formed in the initial 300 ms phase, and the conscious mind becomes aware of the impending response in the final 200 ms phase. When the response is a physical act, the conscious mind is a passive observer. When the conscious mind is an active participant, the response is conscious deliberation.

You can treat the symptoms of a disease until it becomes resistant to treatment, and then the disease must be cured, and a disease is not cured by treating its symptoms. Instead, a cure begins with understanding the disease’s root cause. Then, and only then, does an effective way to eradicate the disease from the body become obvious. The principle applies to an individual’s body and to the body politic.

Cruelty is a voluntary act by humans causing unnecessary suffering experienced by other humans, and it is the product of immoral intent. So, we need to understand the root cause of immoral intent, and that involves understanding Libet’s experiment.

Q: Is intent synonymous with unconscious intent?

A: Yes.

Q: Does that mean unconscious intent is moral or immoral?

A: Yes.

Q: How is unconscious intent moral or immoral?

A: In a word, maturity. Maturity is the intent to create something of lasting value without causing unnecessary harm, and immaturity is the intent to create something of limited value without concern for unnecessary harm.

Q: How does the conscious mind function?

A: If unconscious intent informs and triggers a physical act, then the conscious mind is a passive observer. Otherwise, unconscious intent is informing and triggering conscious deliberation, and then the conscious mind is an active participant.

Q: Why are so many people immature?

A: Because the misdiagnosed disease is evolving to the point that treatments that are effective in limited contexts are largely ineffective in a broader context.

It is not surprising when a potentially effective response to a crisis is unorthodox. “Due process” is how that potential is realized, but it is not surprising when the response is initially ignored.

Q: Why do people ignore due process?

A: Because of the 300 ms cognitive process that forms unconscious intent.

Q: What now?

A: Apply due process to the field of psychology’s current understanding of its most important experiment. That will reveal a correct understanding. It is then, and only then, that an effective way to eradicate the disease from the body politic becomes obvious.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts