Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sanjeev's avatar

It's ludicrous to think that all Evil has somehow accumulated in CIA and US Govt. It's not. Evil is plenty and it's everywhere. It's also in KGB, Russian Oligarchs, Kremlin, Siloviki and Nomenklatura. It's also in CCP & Chinese oligarchs. It's also in 3rd world nations with Nuclear weapons like Indian Fascists Modi, BJP, RSS & Hindutva organizations (many of them are also active in US). There's also Evil in Iranian Mullahs and Islamofascist regimes like Erdogan. It's also in Streets of London, British plutocrats & Royal family.

This is a nonlinear uncertain world and its continuously changing. US was bad guy for dropping Atomic bomb on Japan 78 years ago. But US also helped rebuilding of Japan and US-Japan are now the closest of allies. Of course this doesn't absolve US of it's mistake but both countries have turned on that chapter of book towards a future of partnership.

What about Russia? Russia allied with Hitler (Molotov-Ribbentrop pact) to divide & conquer Europe. Both Stalin & Hitler were devious scoundrels planning to stab each other in back at right opportunity (read Icebreaker). In run up to WW2, Stalin envisioned Hitler fighting with British & French, all forces decimating each other and Russians will come to pick up the pieces. Russia & Germany started the WW2 but Hitler was first to stab Stalin seizing the right opportunity.

US did NOT start WW2. When Hitler got too powerful and Stalin realized his mistake, US came to rescue with lend lease plan that provided industrial backing to Soviet war effort. Khrushchev admitted that Russia wouldn't have survived without US assistance. Dropping A-bomb on Japan was however a huge mistake. But US then help build Europe & Japan (Marshall plan).

But on present situation. Russia is the one threatening world with Nuclear war, wiping out Ukraine & Europe. US has NOT made any such threats. US posed no threat to Russia. Ukraine posed no threat to Russia. Prigozhin admitted that before he tried his coup but failed & killed by Putin. Gen Leonid Ivashov claimed the same thing even before start of Russian aggression.

Historical events offers clues to present & future but they have to be analyzed & understood with proper perspective. The perspective of people like Noam Chomsky, Jeffery Sachs, Ray McGovern etc is that they are still trapped in days of Neocon era - "US is bad. Russia is good. CIA bad." The world has changed a lot but these people didn't update their intellectual firmwares.

Expand full comment
Madeline Taylor, PhD's avatar

Thanks so much, Bandy, for this sobering look at where we are on this planet. Einstein also said something like, "we can't solve a problem with the same mindset that caused the problem in the first place." So another way of understanding why the "civilized" world has drifted toward catastrophe is that most of the people who COULD do something about the proliferation of nuclear weapons and the international conditions that portend their use, are stuck in an old way of thinking. It's not enough to elect one President although who's at the top of the hierarchy makes a huge difference. The People would have to affect individual members of the Joint Chiefs, the House, the Senate, perhaps every member of the U.N.

Tragically, when scientists revealed the potentially catastrophic consequences of climate change 30 or 40 years ago, not enough of the people who could have altered policies, including auto manufacturers and the oil industry, nor any but a small handful of global citizens, organized sufficiently to brainstorm real preventative solutions. Yet we all remember that when there was a competition for dominating space and JFK unleashed the research money, things happened relatively quickly. Competition where there are winners and losers always energizes certain kinds of people. A catastrophic situation where we'd all be "winners" or we'd all be "losers," tragically, doesn't galvanize the same response.

But please keep on writing and we'll keep on circulating this message. We definitely need to do some creative thinking about how to bring this issue back into the public's mind.

worldbeyondwar.org.

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts