Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Rudoff's avatar

I subscribe to Dr Lee's newsletter, but I may or may not be able to be present for the zoom call -- family obligations.

If I cannot make it, someone here please introduce this thought:

In 2016-7, Dr Lee, understanding the threat Trump represents, convened her conference of experts and published her book. She did her best, and, slowly, the concept of a 'malignant narcissist sociopath' has justly entered standard discourse about Trump. She was professionally abused for this -- also, I think, unjustly.

But in the past few months -- I noted this years ago; I am a physician -- it is evident that Trump has a significant dementing illness, an organic brain syndrome. This of course is superimposed on, and distinguishable from, his personality-disorder, his ignorance, and his stupidity. Whether his dementia is Lewy Body, FTD, vascular/lacunar, or ordinary Alzheimer's, I don't know. I am not a neurologist.

I would like to suggest to Dr Lee that a panel --a few dozen, ideally-- of qualified, experienced, practicing neurologists and MD/PhD neuropsychologists be convened to study his filmed public appearances, rally speeches, and published tweets. They should then meet, and deliver an observation-based diagnosis of his dementia.

Most of what a neurologist and psychologist works with is observation. Psychometric testing can (and should) confirm or disconfirm those observations, of course. But experienced neurologists can (and should) weigh in on what is plain, videotaped, and in front of us all. As observers have noted: 'The Trump we see today is the best we will ever see. He will never be better than he is right now.'

An expert like Dr Lee warned the world.

An expert like Timothy Snyder warned the world.

Neurologist/Neuropsychologist experts must warn the world.

If the world survives (which, by the way, I doubt) there should at least be a record that 'someone sounded the alarm.'

Expand full comment
Jen Andrews's avatar

I don't have anything to add until I hear what you say. It's difficult to listen to this braying ass just because of what he's done to this country. It's difficult to offer insight when I am not dispassionate.

Look forward to your take. I hope it doesn't get too technical but is very accessible to most Americans.

Thank you. Someone needs to do this.

Expand full comment
25 more comments...

No posts