Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ric's avatar
Sep 9Edited

The APA's rewriting and promotion of the "Goldwater Rule" to make it harder for psychiatrists to warn the public about the danger of a public figure reminds me of Ralph Waldo Emerson's comment that “an institution is the lengthened shadow of one man,” which is another way to say institutions are all-too-easily instruments of Ego.

A serious weakness in our psychiatry is our inability to appreciate how easily rational thought pursuing truth is contaminated by our subconscious, self-oriented Ego.

Ego evaluates and sees truth in terms of itself. Freud's articulation of the dynamics of Self as being a product of Ego/SuperEgo/Id is an Egoic view of humanity. The triumvirate of Ego/SuperEgo/Id gives equal weight to all three, allowing Ego to run amuck. In an Egoic society, truth is the first victim.

Psychology needs a Copernican revolution where we recognize Self does not revolve around Ego, but amidst truth other than itself.

Acknowledging truth requires identifying, sidelining, seeing-through, taming, and even participating in the annihilation of our subconscious Ego, revealing a different view of existence. Practicing psychology, science or, spirituality without Ego is as socially radical an idea as Ralph Waldo Emerson's philosophy.

Expand full comment
Ken1's avatar

Dr. Lee, several years ago, a physician-author published a book (which you might know) called “The Emperor of Maladies: A Biography of Cancer”, that won the Pulitzer Prize for Non-Fiction in 2011. The title suggested to me that Trump, being a mental cancer, might aptly be called “The Emperor of Psychological Maladies” for purposes of the Conference or otherwise.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts